AgentCentre Education

How to Assess a Property Manager’s Judgement.

Use practical interview scenarios to explore how a property manager weighs urgency, checks information and decides when to seek help. Look closely at the reasons behind their decisions.

A property manager may know the software and speak confidently about their portfolio. You still need to understand how they make decisions when information is incomplete, several matters compete for attention or a client wants an immediate answer.

Choose a few situations they would encounter in your agency. Ask what they would do first, what they need to know and what would happen next.

Start with competing priorities

Present a simple scenario:

“You arrive to several messages: a tenant reports water entering a property, an owner wants a leasing update and a contractor needs access confirmed. How would you approach the morning?”

Allow the candidate to ask questions. What sort of water issue is it? Is anyone at risk? When is the contractor attending?

Useful judgement starts with establishing the facts. Listen for how they assess urgency, arrange help and keep the other matters from being forgotten.

Then change one detail. For example, the tenant cannot be reached. Ask how that affects their next step.

Explore a request they should question

Ask:

“An owner gives you an instruction you believe may create a problem. How would you respond?”

Invite a real example if they have one. Explore how they would check the relevant requirements, explain their concern and offer an appropriate way forward.

Listen for whether they recognise the limits of their knowledge and authority. A confident promise to follow the owner’s instructions without checking deserves further questions.

You are assessing their approach here. Detailed knowledge of legislation can be checked separately.

Test how they handle conflicting accounts

Try this scenario:

“A tenant says a repair has not been completed. The contractor says the job is finished. What would you do?”

Ask what records they would review, what questions they would put to each person and how they would establish the current condition.

Look for a fair, factual approach. The candidate should be able to explain what remains unconfirmed and how they would keep the matter moving.

Ask when they would involve a manager

“Tell me about a matter you escalated. Why did you decide it needed help?”

Then ask what they had already checked, what information they gave their manager and what they remained responsible for afterwards.

Compare their approach with the authority and support available in your role. Someone used to close supervision may need help taking on broader responsibility. Someone used to working alone may need clearer guidance on when to involve you.

Follow the decision through

For each scenario, ask:

  • What would you record?

  • Who needs an update?

  • What would trigger further action?

  • How would you know the matter was resolved?

These questions reveal whether the candidate follows a decision through to completion.

Record the evidence

Use the same core scenarios for each candidate. Note how they establish facts, recognise urgency, work within their authority and follow up.

Give credit for sensible questions and a willingness to check. Where an answer concerns you, ask the candidate to explain their reasoning before reaching a conclusion.

Filed Under
Back to Education Library